.png)
Lightroom Presets vs Custom Editing: Which Is Right for You?
When deciding how to edit your photos, the choice often comes down to Lightroom presets or custom editing. Each has its strengths:
- Lightroom Presets: Fast, one-click adjustments for a consistent style across many photos. Great for beginners or bulk editing (e.g., weddings or social media).
- Custom Editing: Offers full control for detailed, unique edits tailored to each image. Ideal for complex lighting, fine art, or commercial projects.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Lightroom Presets | Custom Editing |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Instant adjustments | Time-consuming |
| Consistency | Uniform for similar lighting | Varies based on skill |
| Learning Curve | Easy to start | Requires advanced knowledge |
| Flexibility | Limited | Full control over every detail |
| Best For | Bulk edits, social media | Unique, detailed projects |
Tip: Many photographers combine both - starting with presets for speed, then fine-tuning with custom edits for precision. Choose based on your workflow, skills, and project needs.
Can Presets Replace Actually Learning How to Edit in Lightroom?
Understanding Lightroom Presets
Lightroom presets are like shortcuts for editing your photos. With just one click, they adjust settings such as exposure, contrast, and saturation to give your images a consistent look across the board [4].
"Presets move your sliders for you to a 'preset' location."
Why Use Lightroom Presets?
Presets can save you a ton of time, especially when you're working through a large batch of photos, like after a wedding or a client shoot [1]. They also help you keep a uniform style across your images, which is great for building a cohesive portfolio [2].
If you're new to photo editing, presets can help you achieve polished results without needing advanced skills. They also double as learning tools - by studying how presets adjust sliders, you can better understand the editing process [1][2].
Potential Downsides of Lightroom Presets
The main issue with presets is that they apply the same adjustments to every photo, regardless of differences in lighting or exposure. This can sometimes result in uneven edits, especially if your photos vary a lot in their original settings [4].
Over-relying on presets might also hold you back from growing as an editor. Plus, using widely available presets without tweaking them can make your work look similar to everyone else's [1][2].
Another thing to note: presets aren't magic. They work best on well-shot photos but won't fix problems like bad exposure or incorrect white balance [4]. Knowing these limits can help you decide whether presets fit your workflow or if you'd benefit more from custom editing.
While presets offer convenience and speed, custom editing gives you the control to tailor each photo to its unique characteristics.
What Is Custom Editing?
Custom editing means adjusting photos individually to meet their specific needs. This includes tweaking elements like exposure, contrast, and color grading. Unlike presets, which apply the same changes to all images, custom editing allows for detailed, image-specific adjustments. It's perfect for professional or artistic projects that require a unique touch.
Why Choose Custom Editing?
Custom editing offers precise control over your images. You can make adjustments to certain areas while leaving others untouched, which is especially useful for challenging lighting or complex color schemes that presets can't handle well [4][5]. It also helps you develop a personal style, making your work stand out in competitive fields.
What Are the Challenges?
The biggest drawback? It takes time. Each photo needs individual attention, which can slow down your workflow - especially with large projects like weddings [3]. Custom editing also demands advanced skills, such as understanding color theory, balancing exposure, and making local adjustments.
Tools like Topaz Denoise and Lightroom can help streamline the process, but consistency takes practice [3][6]. You'll need to master technical details and learn how to tailor adjustments to each photo's unique features.
While custom editing gives you unmatched flexibility, it's worth considering when to use it versus presets for the best balance of efficiency and creativity.
Comparing Lightroom Presets and Custom Editing
Presets work well when you need speed and uniformity, such as for event photography, social media posts, or handling large groups of images with similar lighting. On the other hand, custom editing shines when dealing with unique or intricate images that demand detailed, tailored adjustments.
Let’s break down how these two methods stack up in key areas:
Comparison Table: Presets vs Custom Editing
| Feature | Lightroom Presets | Custom Editing |
|---|---|---|
| Processing Speed | Quick - applies instantly | Slower - requires manual adjustments |
| Consistency | Reliable for similar lighting; less so for varied conditions | Dependent on skill but offers precise control |
| Learning Curve | Easy - little technical knowledge needed | Steeper - requires understanding editing basics |
| Flexibility | Limited to preset settings | Full control over every detail |
| Best Used For | Bulk edits, social media, event photos | Complex lighting, commercial projects, fine art |
| Cost Efficiency | Higher upfront cost, saves time overall | Lower upfront cost, but time-intensive |
"Presets move your sliders for you to a 'preset' location", says Scott Kelby from Lightroom Killer Tips [5].
Aftershoot AI Styles bridges the gap by offering intelligent, image-specific edits. This approach combines the speed of presets with the control of custom editing [4]. Many photographers use a mix of both techniques - starting with presets to save time, then fine-tuning for a polished, professional result.
Conclusion
Deciding between Lightroom presets and custom editing isn’t about choosing the “right” or “wrong” method - it’s about what works best for your creative goals and workflow. Both approaches come with their own strengths, and understanding these can help you make the best choice for your needs.
Custom editing gives you full control, making it perfect for projects like commercial or fine art photography where precision is key. However, it does require a solid grasp of editing techniques and can take up a lot of time.
"AI Styles make dynamic adjustments to every image to ensure the best quality outcome, taking lighting, contrast, white balance, etc. into account for each photo." - Aftershoot Blog [4]
For beginners, presets can be a great way to get started and learn the basics. Over time, you can combine presets for speed with custom edits for fine-tuning as your skills improve.
Here are some points to consider when choosing your approach:
- Time-saving: If you’re working with large batches of photos, presets can significantly cut down your editing time.
- Creative flexibility: Custom editing allows you to craft a unique look tailored to your artistic vision.
- Project demands: Think about what your clients expect and the type of photography you’re doing.
Whether you stick to presets, dive into custom editing, or mix the two, the key is building a workflow that’s both efficient and aligned with your creative style.
Resources for Lightroom Presets and Editing Tools
Whether you're into the convenience of presets or prefer fine-tuning every detail, the right tools can streamline your editing process and help you achieve your creative vision.
Presets.io offers a variety of Lightroom presets designed for different photography styles. From modern to vintage and even cinematic looks, their collection caters to a wide range of artistic preferences.
To complement your presets, consider these essential editing tools:
- Adobe Lightroom: Great for organizing and managing your photos.
- Photoshop: Perfect for detailed retouching and advanced edits.
- Topaz Denoise: A reliable option for reducing noise in your images.
- Capture One: Known for its precise color adjustment features.
- Aftershoot AI Styles: Useful for smart batch editing and saving time.
When choosing preset providers, ensure they offer clear installation instructions and that the presets are compatible with your version of Lightroom. The best tools are those that fit seamlessly into your workflow and match your level of expertise, letting you focus on creating instead of troubleshooting.
Adobe Lightroom’s user-friendly interface makes it a solid choice for both beginners and seasoned editors. Its wide range of features supports everything from quick preset applications to detailed, custom edits.
With these tools in hand, you’ll be better equipped to refine your editing style and bring your creative ideas to life.
FAQs
Do professional photographers use Lightroom presets?
Yes, many professional photographers use Lightroom presets, but they do so thoughtfully. Presets are often a starting point, helping to establish an initial look that can then be fine-tuned to suit each image's unique requirements [1]. What sets professionals apart is their solid grasp of editing principles, which allows them to use presets effectively:
- They understand how presets alter image settings.
- They know when and how to tweak preset settings.
- They align presets with their personal editing style.
- They shift between presets and custom editing seamlessly.
Different photography genres have varying needs. For instance, event photographers often rely on presets for consistency across a large number of images and to meet tight deadlines [1]. On the other hand, commercial and fine art photographers may lean more on custom editing to achieve detailed, precise results [3].
Most professionals use a mix of both approaches. This blend of presets for efficiency and custom edits for precision allows them to stay productive while retaining creative control [1][3].
Pro Tip: Start by learning manual editing. This foundation will make it easier to adjust presets to your liking and know when custom edits are the better option [2].
